Comparison
Cyanotype vs SolarFast
Both are sun-printing processes, but they differ in color, washing, exposure and cost. Here is how they compare.
Download the PDF| Topic | Cyanotype | SolarFast |
|---|---|---|
| Color | Prints are always blue. They can be toned to brown, yellow or black with post-treatments, but the first print is always blue. | Available in 14 mixable colors, for photographic prints in almost any color. Finished prints can't be toned to other colors. |
| Washing | Works on fabric and paper, but printed fabric must be laundered carefully. Only non-phosphate detergents can be used, and prints can fade or discolor with washing. | Permanent on paper and fabric, and can be laundered like any commercially dyed fabric. Exceptionally washfast. |
| When you print | Prints are made once the sensitizer has dried, so coated paper and fabric can be stockpiled for later. There's no risk of staining the negative. | Prints are made while the dye is still damp, so they must be made right after coating. The negative may get stained during contact printing (SolarFast Film can be wiped clean). |
| Tonal range | Produces a broader range of tones and detail than many SolarFast colors. | Some colors produce a narrower range of tones than cyanotype. |
| Cost | Very economical. The chemistry can be bought as powders and used to coat large pieces inexpensively. | Only available as a liquid, and may not go as far as cyanotype chemistry. |
| Pretreated fabric | Jacquard offers pretreated cyanotype fabrics that are ready to use. | Because it must be exposed while damp, pretreated fabrics aren't available. |
| Mixed media | Prone to discoloration, which makes mixed media and over-dyeing somewhat risky. | Great for mixed media. Prints can be embellished and over-dyed without risk. |
| Processing | Processed in cold water. Hydrogen peroxide (optional, cheap and easy to find) is the only other chemical used. | Must be washed in hot water after exposure. SolarFast Wash is highly recommended for the first wash. |
| History | Around for more than 150 years, so there's plenty of information available. | Invented by Jacquard Products in 2013. |
| Exposure time | Short: 3 to 15 minutes, depending on conditions. | Generally longer: 10 to 25 minutes, depending on conditions. |
| Consistency | The sensitizer is usually a liquid with the consistency of water. It can be thickened with SolarFast Thickener. | Comes thickened so it won't bleed or spread on fabric. Can be thinned with water or thickened further with SolarFast Thickener. |
| How color forms | A pigment forms within the fiber. | A true dye that develops color in UV light and bonds chemically to the fiber. |
| Learning curve | Generally considered forgiving and easy. | More of a learning curve, but also easy to do. |
| Large prints | Made on dry materials, so full-body mural prints and handprints are easy. | Made while the dye is damp, so full-body mural prints can be messy. |
| Shelf life | Made from two stock solutions that have a very short shelf life once mixed. | A one-part system with a long shelf life. |