Guide
Toning cyanotype prints
Change the color of finished cyanotype prints with toners.
Download the PDFPeter Henry Emerson, an early champion of photography as art, once wrote that "no one but a vandal would print a landscape in red, or in cyanotype." Around 1890 the Prussian blue of cyanotype wasn't considered very tasteful, so a culture grew up of "toning" blue prints to more subdued colors.
There are many ways to tone cyanotypes. Here are the simplest and least toxic, for toning prints on paper or fabric to browns, blacks, purples and yellows.
The basics
Toning usually takes two steps:
- Bleach: a high pH chemical "reduces" the blue iron color, usually to golden yellow.
- Tone: tannins bond to the reduced iron and change the color of the print.
All the methods below are variations on these two steps.
Experiment
There's no right way to tone a print, so have fun with it. Toning isn't an exact science and results can be unpredictable. Mix and match toners, skip steps or change their order. You can often get three distinct results by skipping the bleach, bleaching after toning, or repeating the sequence. Different drying and washing times between steps also change the result.
Keep in mind
- Start with an overexposed print if you plan to bleach. Underexposed prints often tone nicely with no bleach at all.
- Let the print dry at least 24 hours before toning, or results may be erratic.
- Wet the dry print just before toning so the bleach and toner soak in evenly.
- Either leave the print face down in the toner for a long time, or keep it moving. Avoid air bubbles, which leave untoned blue spots.
Post-treatments that aren't toning
- Hydrogen peroxide: a dilute peroxide bath after the first wash instantly brings the blue to full strength. The print would get there on its own over about 24 hours as it dries and oxidizes. Great for instant gratification.
- Vinegar wash: white wine vinegar in the first wash increases the tonal range and lowers the overall contrast: the highlights get bluer and the midtones show more subtlety. The strength of the vinegar changes how much.
- Vinegar bath after developing: a vinegar bath after washing in water usually increases contrast, with deeper shadows and whiter highlights.
Step 1: bleach
- The most common bleach is soda ash (sodium carbonate), usually 1 to 2 teaspoons in about 1 liter of water. Make sure it's fully dissolved before the print goes in, or you may get speckles.
- You can also bleach with soap, detergent, ammonia or chlorine bleach. Ammonia tends to give a browner image. Chlorine bleach damages fibers and isn't recommended.
- Bleaching breaks down the iron so the tannins in the toner can bond more easily. It's usually quick, under 5 minutes, depending on the density of the print, the strength of the bath and the toner you'll use. If your water is heavily chlorinated you may not need to bleach at all, and sometimes you won't want to.
- Bleach too far and the print loses density: shadows go pale and midtones can vanish. Bleach too little and the shadows stay blue while the midtones tone. That split-tone effect can be interesting in itself.
- Leave the print in until it's an even golden yellow, then quickly put it in water to stop the bleaching. Pull it a few seconds early, since it keeps bleaching for a bit in the water. If you want a golden yellow and white print, you're done. If the print turns bright purple as soon as it goes in, the bleach is too strong.
Step 2: tone
The range of toned colors is fairly narrow (brown, black, purple, yellow, navy), but within it you can get a wide variety of effects. For printing in almost any color, use SolarFast. Some toners work faster and stain less, others give more possibilities. The paper or fabric itself will probably stain at least a little. Weaker toner solutions stain less but take longer.
- Tea: every type and brand of tea gives a different color. Tea works well with minimal bleaching but needs a long soak, usually 2 hours or more (up to 24). Fresh, hot tea is faster but stains more. Use teas with tannins, like black or green tea. White, red and most herbal teas don't have enough. To reduce staining, soak toned prints in clean water for at least 10 minutes.
- Green tea: tends to give a warm eggplant black and doesn't stain the paper badly. Skip the bleach for a greenish black. It sometimes leaves pinkish highlights, an interesting split-tone.
- Black tea: stains the most, but gives a unique rich warm black-brown. After heavy bleaching it gives a beautiful neutral brown. With minimal bleaching you may get a split-tone, with warm highlights and cool shadows.
- Coffee: for the truest black, coffee is usually best. It gives a cool black (tea's black is warm), stains less, works faster than tea and works remarkably well without bleaching. Instant coffee works as well as brewed.
- Tannic acid: the original cyanotype toner. It gives an even brown with a lot of staining.
- Wine tannin: used in brewing and winemaking, it's like tannic acid but dissolves more easily and is easier to find. It gives a beautifully even warm black (split-tones are rare) with little staining.
- Red wine: contains tannins and tones prints a purplish black. Staining is almost unavoidable because of its color, but it can be an interesting effect.
- Borax: probably the most unpredictable toner. It can give a violet print, usually without bleaching, but results vary.
- Soda ash: as in the bleach step, soda ash alone gives a yellow tone. A very dilute bath can give a blue and yellow split-tone, or even more dilute, a navy print. It's very sensitive and takes practice.
- Combinations: combining toners, changing the order and repeating steps gives a huge variety of results. Experiment and make your own discoveries.
Note: The example prints for each method are in the PDF.